Think about the last time someone asked you to bend a safety rule just this once. Maybe it was a visiting student who wanted to participate in a case, a colleague running late asking for the resident to start the case, or a confident surgeon who is anxious to go to his clinic and asks the nurse to skip the instrument count. Saying yes would have cost nothing that day as it is an innocent sounding request. It would recognize that the person meant well.
That is exactly how protocols erode. Nobody decides to abandon them. They wear down one reasonable exception at a time, until the exception becomes the way things are done and nobody remembers why the rule existed.
A no that lasted decades
Years ago, a medical student asked Daniele to let him observe a shunt operation. Because shunt surgery is especially vulnerable to infection, access to the operating room is restricted to only people performing a role. Daniele said no to the student, and he explained why.
Earlier this year, that student, now a neurosurgical attending, became the first recipient to hold the endowed chair in Daniele’s name at Johns Hopkins Medicine. At the dinner celebrating this event, the accomplished young attending mentioned this interaction when he was turned away from years back. He said it was the lesson he remembered most during his neurosurgical training. He realized that incident made him very cognizant about the risk of infection and of the importance of respecting protocol.
A single no, delivered with a reason, shaped how another surgeon has protected his patients. That is the leverage a teacher holds in these small moments, and it explains why each moment matters so much.
Why the explanation matters as much as the rule
A rule enforced without explanation requires people to comply with the protocol. A rule explained teaches them to always adhere to it and consistently protect the patient. The latter approach is particularly critical in situations under pressure: the night shift, the weekend case, the rushed handoff.
The evidence for consistency is strong. When eight hospitals introduced a 19-item surgical safety checklist, complications fell from 11 percent to 7 percent and deaths from 1.5 percent to 0.8 percent [1]. Checklists only work when the whole team follows them every time. People are more likely to follow protocols every time when they understand the safety each step protects.
Creativity inside the rules
Holding the line doesn’t require shutting the door on learning. One option to let learners observe a sterile procedure could be to have either an observation window or a camera recording the procedure so students can watch a case without adding risk to it. The best answers to “just this once” often come from asking a better question: how do we meet this need without breaking the rule?
What leaders can do this week
- Pick one safety protocol and ask your team where exceptions have crept in. Listen without blame.
- When you say no, give the reason in one sentence. Make it about safety for the patient.
- Model the protocol yourself in front of your team.
- Recognize someone who held the line this month. Say publicly why it mattered.
The leaders people remember are often the ones who said no for the right reason. If you would like help building an environment where people hold the line and are able to explain why, we would be glad to talk with you.
Reference
[1] Haynes AB, Weiser TG, Berry WR, et al. A surgical safety checklist to reduce morbidity and mortality in a global population. N Engl J Med. 2009;360:491-9.
