In a hospital I worked with, leadership rolled out a new attendance policy to bring absenteeism down. On paper, it was reasonable.
Yet no one had consulted the people that the policy would affect the most such as the night-shift nurses, many of whom were juggling childcare or eldercare around their shifts.
Within a month, the number of people not showing up to work spiked.
Although nurses were committed, they felt unseen. Trust took a hit, and the very problem the policy was meant to fix got worse.
If you lead HR, this story is for you
The people who wrote that policy were not uncaring. They were doing what overwhelmed leaders often do: solving the problem they could see from where they sat. Good intentions do not erase harmful impact, and a policy written without talking with the people affected most will most likely fail to address the problem it was intended to fix.
When several staff members are calling in sick they are sending a message. They are telling you, in the only way available to them, that something in the schedule is not working. If the response is a stricter rule, you may be addressing the problem incorrectly.
A policy not reflecting the staff realities tells people you are presuming to know what their lives look like without asking them. Compassionate communication means asking staff who will be affected by the policy for their opinion before you announce a new policy. This shows you value them and their opinion.
Four questions to ask before your next policy rollout
- Who will this policy touch most, and have I spoken with them? Start with nights, weekends and any shift leadership rarely visits.
- What is going on in their lives that the policy does not know about? Childcare and eldercare are two I have seen.
- If I asked five people who called in sick last month what was happening in their lives that week, what would they say?
- How will we know in thirty days whether this policy is working, and who will ask the people it affects?
One thing to do this week
Pick one policy your organization rolled out in the past year. Ask five of the people it affected, ideally including someone from the night shift, what it changed for them. Write down what you hear before you plan any policy adjustments.
If you would like a partner in that conversation, book a time with me at TalkWithDrKaren.com.
P.S. I discuss this type of issues in my upcoming book, Leadership That Heals.
